|Jay Baruchel||Reed Fish|
|Alexis Bledel||Kate Peterson|
|Schuyler Fisk||Jill Cavanaugh|
|Victor Rasuk||Frank Cortez|
|A. J. Cook||Theresa|
In this comedy inspired by the screenwriter's life, Reed Fish hosts a call-in radio show that reports on the minutiae of life in his tiny town -- the job his dad had before Reed stepped into it. Reed is also about to marry local sweetheart Kate . Those plans are rocked by the return of Jill, Reed's first great love, who left for college years ago. His rekindled feelings make Reed start to reconsider a life built on what other people expect of him.