|Tony Hale||Sam No. 2|
|Zoe Kazan||Mary Catherine|
|Josh Radnor||Sam Wexler|
|Jimmy Gary Jr.||Officer Jones|
|Richard Jenkins||Paul Gertmanian|
Young New Yorkers try to navigate a rocky course of careers and personal relationships. Sam, an aspiring novelist, takes in a boy he saw abandoned on the subway. Sam's best friend, Annie, suffers from alopecia and finds herself torn between two men, one good, one bad. Meanwhile, Sam meets an aspiring singer, who may be the one to break his endless stream of one-night stands.